291
edits
Changes
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Line 265:
Line 265: + + + + + + + + +
→Image guidelines: outdent discussion back to no-indent; will proceed with proposed Special Order file as-is, and discussion continues on Help Wanted.
::::Ahh, I see. Would a cropped version be preferable for the Help Wanted Board? Do you have any preference on the "!" request available icon being present or not for both cases? [[User:Techhead7890|Techhead7890]] ([[User talk:Techhead7890|talk]]) 15:01, 17 July 2022 (UTC)
::::Ahh, I see. Would a cropped version be preferable for the Help Wanted Board? Do you have any preference on the "!" request available icon being present or not for both cases? [[User:Techhead7890|Techhead7890]] ([[User talk:Techhead7890|talk]]) 15:01, 17 July 2022 (UTC)
:::::I honestly don't think we need the image at all. In looking at the [[Quests]] page, there is ample text under "List of Special Orders" for us to insert an image without adversely affecting the flow of the page. But the "Help Wanted Quests" section already has less text and a large image that continues into the "Achievements" section on wide screens. I also think describing the location of the "help wanted" board is sufficient, really. [[User:Margotbean|margotbean]] ([[User talk:Margotbean|talk]]) 15:18, 17 July 2022 (UTC)
:::::I honestly don't think we need the image at all. In looking at the [[Quests]] page, there is ample text under "List of Special Orders" for us to insert an image without adversely affecting the flow of the page. But the "Help Wanted Quests" section already has less text and a large image that continues into the "Achievements" section on wide screens. I also think describing the location of the "help wanted" board is sufficient, really. [[User:Margotbean|margotbean]] ([[User talk:Margotbean|talk]]) 15:18, 17 July 2022 (UTC)
┌──────────┘
For the Help Wanted file first: I feel like such a photo would give significantly more context to the information provided, which is generally my goal when editing, regardless if the location is described or not. This is because it let players know what to expect when they go looking for that object, so personally I disagree about the usefulness/necessity.
I also don't think that overflowing the section is that much of a deal, especially as it would only flow into the next subsection, which is still related to the Help Wanted Board and full of text that would just reflow around the image. In my editing opinion, I don't think that prose length should really dictate that sort of decision. Also, the draft image is also less than 250px square, which is about the half of most building infobox images, which when combined with the Valley map do currently overflow.
As an alternative, I think it might simply be possible to put the whole [[:File:Pierres shop.png]] photo there as a reference, if that helps avoid issues with translations (that you mentioned earlier) and such. But I think in general it is useful to have a representation of the board, and/or an image of the board's location in some form. That being said, there was tremendous variety when looking up information on small objects in the game for precedent, but do let me know your thoughts about how to proceed there if at all.
As for the Special Order Board, which you already mentioned above (17 July) has sufficient general image quality: I'm assume that the ! icon isn't that important, so I'll just upload that one and insert it into the page (and a belated thanks for checking through it before). [[User:Techhead7890|Techhead7890]] ([[User talk:Techhead7890|talk]]) 01:43, 19 July 2022 (UTC)
== Custom styles for modding namespace ==
== Custom styles for modding namespace ==